Jump To: All Cigars | Cuban Cigars | Non-Cuban Cigars |
Goodfellas offers an extensive collection of cigarillos, machine made and mass market cigars. If you don't see something you are searching for, please let us know and we are happy to try to source it for you.
Everything listed below is typically in stock unless we encounter abnormal supply issues. If legally allowable, we offer single sales of cigarillos.
Updated November, 2025.
At this time, please call or email to inquire about mail order tobacco. We are happy to ship!
Please bear in mind that selection differs between our two locations. Please confirm availability with us to avoid disappointment.
| Product | Blend/Flavour | Pack Size |
| Al's Mini Cigarillos | Mini R | Pack of 20 |
| Al's Mini Cigarillos | Mini J | Pack of 20 |
| Al's Whisky Cigarillos | 10 Pack | |
| Amigos by Neos Cigarillos | Original (Medium) | Box of 50 |
| Amigos by Neos Cigarillos | Full | Box of 50 |
| Backwoods Cigars | Original | 5 Pack |
| Backwoods Cigars | Whisky (Sweet Aromatic) | 5 Pack |
| Backwoods Cigars | Rum | 5 Pack |
| Backwoods Cigars | Wine (Honey) | 5 Pack |
| Backwoods Cigars | Port (Honey Berry) | 5 Pack |
| Bullseye Filtered Cigarillos | Original | Pack of 20 |
| Bullseye Filtered Cigarillos | B (Mild) | Pack of 20 |
| Cafe Creme Cigarillos | Original | Pack of 20 |
| Cafe Creme Cigarillos | Sky (Mild) | Pack of 20 |
| Cohiba Clubs 20 Pack Cigarillos | Pack of 20 | |
| Cohiba Minis 20 Pack Cigarillos | Pack of 20 | |
| Cohiba Shorts Cigarillos | Pack of 10 | |
| Colts M (Mini) Cigarillos | Wine | Pack of 8 |
| Colts M (Mini) Cigarillos | Original | Pack of 8 |
| Colts Tipped Cigarillos | Cavendish | Pack of 8 |
| Colts Tipped Cigarillos | Original | Pack of 8 |
| Colts Tipped Cigarillos | Rum & Wine | Pack of 8 |
| Colts Tipped Cigarillos | Rum & Wine Label (Mild) | Pack of 8 |
| Colts Tipped Cigarillos | Whisky | Pack of 8 |
| Corto Cigarillos | Box of 50 | |
| El Guajiro Trabuco T-10 Cigarillos | Bundle of 25 | |
| El Guajiro Trompeta Cigarillos | Pack of 20 | |
| Frontwoods Wine | Wine | 5 Pack |
| Guantanamera Minis 20 Pack Cigarillos | Pack of 20 | |
| Guantanamera Puritos Cigarillos | Pack of 5 | |
| HOH Euro Senoritas Cigarillos | Natural | Box of 50 |
| HOH Euro Senoritas Cigarillos | Maduro | Box of 50 |
| HOH Euro Slim Panatela Cigarillos | Natural | Box of 25 |
| HOH Euro Slim Panatela Cigarillos | Maduro | Box of 25 |
| Jose L. Piedra Minis Cigarillos 20 Pack | Pack of 20 | |
| Majorette Mini Cigarillos | R Original | Pack of 10 |
| Majorette Mini Cigarillos | RR Rum | Pack of 10 |
| Majorette Regular Cigarillos | Pack of 5 | |
| Mehari's Cigarillos | Ecuador (Mild) | Pack of 10 |
| Mehari's Cigarillos | Java (Medium) | Pack of 10 |
| Montecristo Clubs Cigarillos 20 Pack | Pack of 20 | |
| Montecristo Open Clubs 20 Pack Cigarillos | Pack of 20 | |
| Montecristo Open Minis Cigarillos 20 Pack | Pack of 20 | |
| Montecristo Puritos Cigarillos | Pack of 5 | |
| Montecristo Shorts Cigarillos | Pack of 10 | |
| Neos Cigarillos | Safari (Medium) | Pack of 10 |
| Neos Cigarillos | Mirage (Mild) | Pack of 10 |
| Old Port by Colts Cigarillos | Pack of 5 | |
| Panter Cigarillos | Full | Pack of 20 |
| Panter Cigarillos | Sky (Mild) | Pack of 20 |
| Panter Mini Cigarillos | Original (Medium) | Pack of 20 |
| Panter Mini Cigarillos | Sky (Mild) | Pack of 20 |
| Partagas Clubs 20 Pack Cigarillos | Classic | Pack of 20 |
| Partagas Clubs 20 Pack Cigarillos | Serie | Pack of 20 |
| Partagas Minis 20 Pack Cigarillos | Classic | Pack of 20 |
| Partagas Minis 20 Pack Cigarillos | Serie | Pack of 20 |
| Partagas Puritos Cigarillos | Chicos | Pack of 5 |
| Partagas Puritos Cigarillos | Serie | Pack of 5 |
| Phillies Blunt Cigars | Original | Pack of 5 |
| Phillies Blunt Cigars | Berry | Pack of 5 |
| Phillies Blunt Cigars | Chocolate | Pack of 5 |
| Phillies Blunt Cigars | Cognac | Pack of 5 |
| Phillies Blunt Cigars | Grape | Pack of 5 |
| Phillies Blunt Cigars | Strawberry | Pack of 5 |
| Phillies Blunt Cigars | Vanilla | Pack of 5 |
| Pom Pom Cigarillos | Pack of 5 | |
| Pom Pom Mini Original Tipped Cigarillos | Pack of 2 | |
| Pom Pom Mini Wine Tipped Cigarillos | Pack of 2 | |
| Primo Cigarillos | Box of 50 | |
| Romeo y Julieta Clubs 20 Pack Cigarillos | Pack of 20 | |
| Romeo y Julieta Minis 20 Pack Cigarillos | Pack of 20 | |
| Romeo Y Julieta Puritos Cigarillos | Pack of 5 | |
| Sail (Captain Black) Tipped Cigarillos | Classic | Pack of 8 |
| Sail (Captain Black) Tipped Cigarillos | Plantation (Rum) | Pack of 8 |
| Sail (Captain Black) Tipped Cigarillos | Valley (Wine) | Pack of 8 |
| Sail (Captain Black) Tipped Cigarillos | Highland (Whisky) | Pack of 8 |
| Swisher Sweets Mini Cigarillos | Classic (Red) | Pack of 6 |
| Swisher Sweets Mini Cigarillos | Wine (Grape) | Pack of 6 |
| Tabacalera Caprichos Cigarillos | Box of 50 | |
| Tabacalera Cigarillos | Natural | Box of 20 |
| Torres de Nicaragua Rapidito Cigarillos | Bundle of 40 | |
| Toscano Toscanello Cigars | Pack of 5 | |
| Trinidad Shorts Cigarillos | Pack of 10 |