Welcome to Goodfellas Cigar Shop

You must be over 19 to access this website. Are you over the age of 19?

Skip to content
We're still putting the final touches on our new Website. Not all products we carry in store are listed online at this time. Please let us know about any issues or questions you may have about product availability. For mail orders involving tobacco items please contact us. Thank you for understanding.
Contact us to mail order Tobacco products.

Cigarillo & Machine Made Cigars

Jump To: All Cigars | Cuban Cigars | Non-Cuban Cigars |

Goodfellas offers an extensive collection of cigarillos, machine made and mass market cigars.  If you don't see something you are searching for, please let us know and we are happy to try to source it for you. 

Prices are subject to change.

At this time, please call or email to inquire about mail order tobacco.  We are happy to ship!

Please bare in mind that the list below does not guarantee items are in stock, as selection differs between our two locations and cigars can become temporarily unavailable.  Please confirm availability with us to avoid disappointment. 

Brand Name Blend Name Size Name Specifications Box/Pack Quantity Origin Country Single Price Box Carton Store
#263 Claro Super Corona 6 x 44 25 Canada $5.25 $119.95 DT/UT
#263 Claro Cadets 5 1/2 x 36 25 Canada $4.50 $102.95 DT/UT
#263 Sweets Super Corona 6 x 44 25 Canada $5.25 $119.95 DT/UT
Al's J Cigarillo 3 1/4 x 18 20 EU N/A $34.95 $165.95 DT/UT
Al's R Cigarillo 3 1/4 x 18 20 EU N/A $34.95 $165.95 DT/UT
Al's Whisky Collection Cigarillo 3 1/2 x 22 10 EU $2.25 $20.95 $99.95 DT/UT
Azan Corto Corto 3 5/8 x 24 50 Nicaragua $1.95 $81.95 DT/UT
Backwoods Original Cigarillo 4 x 27 5 Dominican $17.95 $136.95 DT/UT
Backwoods Original Singles Cigarillo 4 x 27 1 Dominican $4.75 N/A DT/UT
Backwoods Port Cigarillo 4 x 27 5 Dominican $17.95 $136.95 DT/UT
Backwoods Port Singles Cigarillo 4 x 27 1 Dominican $4.75 N/A DT/UT
Backwoods Rum Cigarillo 4 x 27 5 Dominican $17.95 $136.95 DT/UT
Backwoods Whisky Cigarillo 4 x 27 5 Dominican $17.95 $136.95 DT/UT
Backwoods Whisky Singles Cigarillo 4 x 27 1 Dominican $4.75 N/A DT/UT
Backwoods Wine Cigarillo 4 x 27 5 Dominican $17.95 $136.95 DT/UT
Bandi Original Cigarillo 5 x 42 5 Canada $4.75 $17.95 $94.95 DT/UT
Blackstone Port - Out of Stock! Cigarillo 5 x 28 5 USA $4.00 $17.95 $85.95 DT/UT
Bullseye B (Blue) Cigarillo 3 1/3 x 18 20 USA N/A $14.95 $141.95 DT/UT
Bullseye Original Cigarillo 3 1/3 x 18 20 USA N/A $14.95 $141.95 DT/UT
Cafe Creme Original (Yellow) Cigarillo 3 x 22 20 EU N/A $40.50 $192.95 DT/UT
Cafe Creme Sky (Blue) Cigarillo 3 x 22 20 EU N/A $40.50 $192.95 DT/UT
Century Sam Corona Corona 5 x 42 5 Canada $3.10 $14.50 $67.95 DT/UT
Clubmaster Brazil Elegantes 4 1/8 x 28 10 EU $3.45 $31.50 $297.95 DT/UT
Clubmaster Mini Blue Filter Mini 2 3/5 x 19 20 EU N/A $33.95 $161.95 DT/UT
Clubmaster Mini Sumatra (no filter) Mini 3 x 19 20 EU N/A $33.95 $322.95 DT/UT
Clubmaster Sumatra Elegantes 4 1/8 x 28 10 EU $3.45 $31.50 $297.95 DT/UT
Clubmaster Superior Sumatra Superior 3 1/2 x 21 20 EU N/A $37.50 $178.95 DT/UT
Colts Cavendish (Black) - Out of Stock! Cigarillo 4 1/4 x 20 8 EU N/A $17.75 $168.95 DT/UT
Colts Mini Wine Red Cigarillo 3 3/4 x 20 8 EU $2.15 $15.95 DT/UT
Colts Rum & Wine Cigarillo 4 1/4 x 20 8 EU N/A $17.75 $168.95 DT/UT
Colts Rum & Wine Label (Mild) Cigarillo 4 1/4 x 20 8 EU N/A $17.75 $168.95 DT/UT
Colts Special Original (Filtered) Cigarillo 3 1/4 x 20 20 EU N/A $18.25 $86.95 DT/UT
Colts Special Sky (Mild)(Filtered) Cigarillo 3 1/4 x 20 20 EU N/A $18.25 $86.95 UT
Colts Whisky Cigarillo 4 1/4 x 20 8 EU N/A $17.75 $168.95 DT/UT
Don Tomas Clasico Coronitas 4 1/2 x 32 10 Honduras $7.95 $72.50 DT/UT
Guilded (Gold) Band Cubana's N/A Corona 5 x 42 50 Canada $3.50 $154.95 DT/UT
Honey T Spiral Whisky - Out of Stock! Cigarillo 3 3/10 x 18 12 N/A $10.95 $99.95 DT/UT
Macanudo Connecticut Ascot 4 1/8 x 32 10 Dominican $8.95 $81.95 DT/UT
Macanudo Maduro Ascot 4 1/8 x 32 10 Dominican $8.00 $72.95 DT/UT
Majorette N/A Original 4 1/2 x 28 5 Canada $2.25 $10.50 $99.95 DT/UT
Majorette N/A Mini 3 1/2 x 28 10 Canada $2.10 $18.95 $89.95 DT/UT
Majorette N/A Mini Rum 3 1/2 x 28 10 Canada $2.10 $18.95 $89.95 DT/UT
Mehari's by Agio Ecuador (Blue-Mild) Cigarillo 3 7/8 x 23 10 EU $2.85 $24.95 $236.95 DT/UT
Mehari's by Agio Java (Brown-Medium) Cigarillo 3 7/8 x 23 10 EU $2.85 $24.95 $236.95 DT/UT
Neos Mirage (Mild) Cigarillo 4 x 24 10 Belgium $2.50 $22.50 $106.95 DT/UT
Neos Safari (Regular) Cigarillo 4 x 24 10 Belgium $2.50 $22.50 $106.95 DT/UT
Neos Amigos Original Cigarillo 3 3/4 x 24 50 Belgium $1.90 $86.96 DT/UT
Old Port by Colts Old Port Tipped 4 1/4 x 20 5 Denmark N/A $17.95 $85.95 DT/UT
Panter Full (Noir/Nuit) Cigarillo 3 x 20 20 EU N/A $39.50 $179.95 DT/UT
Panter Mini Original (Yellow) Cigarillo 3 x 20 20 EU N/A $39.50 $179.95 DT/UT
Panter Mini Sky (Blue) Cigarillo 3 x 20 20 EU N/A $39.50 $179.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Chocolate Blunt 5 x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Coconut - Out of Stock! Blunt 5 x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Cognac Blunt 5 x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Berry Blunt 5 x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Strawberry Blunt 5x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Grape Blunt 5 x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Original (Natural) Blunt 5 x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Phillies Blunt Vanilla Blunt 5 x 42 5 USA $3.75 $16.95 $158.95 DT/UT
Pom Pom 1867 Blunt 4 3/8 x 28 5 USA $3.50 $15.50 $73.95 DT
Primos by Agio Primos Cigarillo 3 7/8 x 23 50 EU $2.15 $92.95 DT/UT
Principes by La Aurora Blond Vanilla Corona 5 1/4 x 40 25 Dominican $5.95 $139.95 DT/UT
Principes by La Aurora Brown Chocolate Corona 5 1/4 x 40 25 Dominican $5.95 $139.95 DT/UT
Principes by La Aurora Caribbean Rum Corona 5 1/4 x 40 25 Dominican $5.95 $139.95 DT/UT
Principes by La Aurora Natural Corona 5 1/4 x 40 25 Dominican $5.95 $139.95 DT/UT
Principes by La Aurora Red Cherry Corona 5 1/4 x 40 25 Dominican $5.95 $139.95 DT/UT
Sail (Captain Black) Classic (Blonde) Cigarillo 3 7/8 x 23 8 EU $2.95 $17.95 $170.95 DT/UT
Sail (Captain Black) Highland (Whisky) Cigarillo 3 7/8 x 23 8 EU $2.95 $17.95 $170.95 DT/UT
Sail (Captain Black) Plantation (Rum) Cigarillo 3 7/8 x 23 8 EU $2.95 $17.95 $170.95 DT/UT
Sail (Captain Black) Valley (Wine) Cigarillo 3 7/8 x 23 8 EU $2.95 $17.95 $170.95 DT/UT
Santa Anna Machine Made Corona 6 x 43 5 Nicaragua $4.00 $18.95 DT/UT
Swisher Mini Original - Out of Stock! Cigarillo 3 1/2 x 24 6 USA $2.65 $14.50 $134.95 DT
Swisher Mini Wine - Out of Stock! Cigarillo 3 1/2 x 24 6 USA $2.65 $14.50 $134.95 DT
Tabacalera N/A Isabela 6 x 43 25 Phillipines $5.95 $129.95 DT/UT
Tabacalera N/A Caprichos 5 1/2 x 27 50 Phillipines $2.95 $129.95 DT/UT
Tabacalera N/A Cigarillo Maduro 4 1/2 x 24 50 Phillipines $2.95 $129.95 DT/UT
Toscano Classico Toscanello 3 x 34 5 Italy $5.50 $25.50 DT/UT
Toscano Classico Classico 6 x 39 5 Italy $7.95 $36.50 DT/UT
Trader Jacks Original - Out of Stock! Corona 6 1/4 x 45 20 USA $6.50 $118.95 DT/UT